Commonwealth Bank website tries to keep up with the Joneses
The Commonwealth Bank (CBA) recently redesigned the website and seems to be committed to improving it further. The new site takes a leaf out of ANZ's book, with some slick graphics, some user centred design elements, icons and interactive Flash elements.
The ANZ site has featured many of these things since mid 2006, and while the Commonwealth Bank obviously aspires to keep up with the competitors, the website is still not quite there. Both banks posted huge profits this year (4.4 billion for CBA and 4.2 billion for ANZ in 2007). Perhaps the mere 200 million difference in profit which separates the two banks accounts for some of the discrepancy, although from the looks of it, I doubt that the Commonwealth Bank spent it on their website. Though I have often been critical of the banks websites, and I find it suprising how many financial services organisations have substandard websites. Of the Big Four major banks, however, the ANZ is the clear leader in this area in my opinion. NAB was quick to follow, but the CBA have been slightly left behind in this department.
So here is a side-by-side comparison of the old and the new for the CBA:

A view of the old look CBA website homepage (above)

A new look for the CBA (above)
So now onto my critical review ..
On the new Commbank site, there are now separate pages for the Personal and Business banking, their two main targets. The sub-sites have been clearly separated this time around and the big improvements have been on effective grouping of secondary navigation elements to reduce clutter. The result is a very clean, corporate look with lots of great whitespace. The site is very easy to read, although the default font size is perhaps a little small for some users, the site invites users to change it.
While the Business section opens in its own window and still has its old look and still needs some work, the Personal Banking section is now sporting a new directory style look which is somewhat easier to navigate. This sort of content packaging is very effective on a financial services website, and the products and information that are relevant are easy to find, with nice pretty pictures for each. Each product and service also has its own template, which features its own navigation and visual icons and panels for e-services tools. There are "Need Assistance" links and icons on most pages and context sensitive "Did you know?" type tips. Relevant disclaimers and disclosure statements are discrete but always visible. The whole thing at least looks very user friendly.
One minor usability criticism, however, (from my own experience as a user) is the inconsistent use and visual treatment of the hyperlinks. Some are underlined, while others aren't. This may seem trivial, but it is a huge issue for me. I actually went to click on the "Apply Now" and "Tools & Calculators" icons. When it didn't do anything I assumed that it didn't work and left it alone. It wasn't hyperlinked. Afterward I realised that the text next to it (which also wasn't visibly hyperlinked) was actually clickable. The same goes for the little yellow arrows on the page. I am a reasonbly savvy user. If I wasn't, such attention to detail it may well have costed them a customer, if not already be costing them thousands of potential customers. Relying on exploratory navigation behaviour can be costly, especially for banks which should be doing their best to take the guesswork out of doing business with consumers and business.
I am a Bendigo and ANZ bank customer, so I can't say whether other aspects such as Internet banking have also improved (perhaps some of our readers may be able to contribute here).
Though the CBA site sports some aspects of a Web2.0 look, unfortunately, according to the Age's article "Web2.0? Don't bank on it just yet" banks like the Commbank seem to be at the conservative end when it comes to implementing Web 2.0 functionality, so you won't find anything too funky just yet.
Comments
By Anna Kluge on 28 September 2009 at 03:44 PM
which agency designed it?
By Sean Fishlock on 09 November 2007 at 02:22 AM
Can you substantiate this claim john ?
By john smith on 08 November 2007 at 06:56 AM
This "new" design was ripped off another agency FYI.
Categories
- Datalink News (23)
- Project News (28)
- People @ Datalink (6)
- Emerging Technologies and Trends (21)
- Best Practice and Strategy (16)
- Web Design & Development (18)
- Internet Marketing (31)
- Website Watch (11)
- Book Reviews (6)
- Datalink Ramblings (17)
- Industry News (5)
- All Categories

