SEO Spam - Sapping Search Results

27 October 2008 - By Sean Fishlock

If you're like me, you'd be sick of false websites appearing in your search results.  You know what I mean, those sites that just contain nothing but ads.  These websites are like leeches on the Internet.  Many a minute has been spent sifting through these useless sites.  Mistype or follow the wrong link and you're lost in a world of ads with nothing good to gain.  It is becoming ever clearer that the effectiveness of the Internet search engines as a tool for finding information.  

As a search engine marketer, you have to know where to draw the lines. We've been preaching SEO for many years, but the sort of blatant SEO spam is a completely different beast and I'll attempt to explain how and why.

Email was blown away by spam many years ago, so it was inevitable thatspamming of search engines would eventually become the next battle tobe fought to keep the Internet a useful tool.  Search engines conquered wave after wave of hidden text and keywords stuffing with new algorithsms and blacklisting until it became stable.  But these days the web is a much bigger place and ironically the biggest culprit of this new plague is the kings of search - Google. Through promoting context advertising services like Adsense and having so many eyes scrutinise their search methods, they have given unscrupulous publishers the motivation to spam their search engine to make money for themselves.  Since then the growing proliferation of "Made for Adsense" (MFA) websites has helped tarnish the Internet.  There are now sophisticated templates used to create doorway pages to roll out by the thousand.

These publishers were even buying advertising for their sites to generate more clicks, effectively making advertising on Google a nasty experience for legitimate advertisers.  They also "scrape" content from other sites using RSS feeds.  Early last year a site began outranking mine in Google.  Not long afterward I discovered that they had spent minutes copying and pasting all of the content which I had spent days creating.  This person had just profited greatly on information which I had been creating for free.  The whole experience forced me to do a major diligent search engine optimisation campaign just to redeem my site and made me rethink the value of the content I was providing.  But this is something I should never have had to do.

So now search engines, torn between their primary revenue stream (advertising) and their reason for existence (making searching the Internet easy) are having to come up with new ways to tackle the issue.
My fast typing gets me into a lot of trouble.  For example when I go to read Hotmail (yes I still use it, but I use Gmail too) I get the all too familiar for me hotmial.com site (pictured below) which is just begging me to mistakenly click on one of their many email promotional links.  I've been waiting years for this useless thing to be removed from the Internet, but alas for me and probably thousands of others like me, I doubt it ever will !


A solution, I tell my client, is to report spam sites to Google.  But most people I've spoken to don't take the time to report SEO spam, because a) they don't know how to identify it properly and b) feel like they can't do anything about it.  And in reality they're probably right.  It is not directly in Google's financial interests to actively promote this service and who knows what action they actually take on these notifications.  The other solution is don't use Google at all (which brings some suprise from some people).  Using social bookmarking is one way of tackling the issue, because computers don't make great quality controllers whereas people do.  On the downside, I'm yet to find a social bookmarking and searching system that rivals Google for pure simplicity.  When one does come along, I'll be straight on board. 

Anyway all this has lessons for the search engine optimiser as well.  If Google doesn't police our Internet, then perhaps we need to apply the laws of Karma, and hope that a good social search engine arrives sooner rather than later.

So I thought I'd jot down some of my fundamental rules and ethics for SEO which help to avoid SEO spam sites (note that I'm still defining them and anyone who wants to chip in is most welcome):

1.  The site must be useful to someone - not just the person whose ads
2.  Adsense should be the bonus, not the focus
3.  Make sure you have permission to use the content and that you are not breaking copyright
4.  Make sure the content is meaningful and in context
5.  Use it to link to your website or promote your service, but not to replace the function of your website

And if you follow these rules, if and when the next generation of social search arrives, your site will do very well.

Comments

There are no comments.


Name *


Comment *


Verification code *


Click to regenerate Regenerate code

Promotional Banner
Creative e-business